Root Canal vs Implant: Cost, Pain, and Success Rate Differences

If you’re dealing with a severely damaged or infected tooth, your dentist may recommend either a root canal or dental implant procedure. But which is better for you? Here, we’ll compare the root canal near me and dental Implant options on critical factors like cost, pain levels, procedure steps, and long-term success rates.

What’s the average cost difference between a root canal and an implant?

The cost difference can be significant. A general dentist near you typically charges $300 to $2,000 per tooth for root canal. This covers the procedure, any anesthesia or medication needed, and a temporary crown. A permanent crown is usually cost around $500 to $3,000 extra.

On the other hand, a single dental implant in North Branch, MI can cost something between $3,000 to $6,000, including the post, abutment, and crown. If you need bone grafting beforehand, that’s another $500 to $2,000.

So, for a single tooth, an implant may cost up to twice as much as a root canal and crown. However, implants are priced per tooth, while root canals may eventually need to be redone. Over time, costs between the two procedures can even out.

Which treatment option usually involves more pain?

Patients often report more pain and discomfort during a root canal compared to getting a dental implant.

During a root canal, the dentist opens the tooth structure and removes the inflamed or infected pulp. This can be painful and tender in the dentist’s chair, even with local anesthesia.

For an implant, there is some pain during the initial surgical placement into the jawbone. But once healed, the implant is painless since it’s an artificial tooth with no nerves. The surrounding gums can be sensitive as they adjust.

With either procedure, over-the-counter pain relievers and ice packs often ease post-treatment discomfort.

What is the procedure like for a root canal versus an implant?

A root canal requires a few steps over multiple appointments:

• The emergency dentist drills an access hole through your enamel and dentin layers. Nerves and blood vessels are taken out. The root canal system is cleaned, molded, and sealed. A temporary filling is placed.
• The permanent filling or crown is cemented on top on the next visit. You’ll return periodically to check that the tooth is still healthy inside and out.

For a dental implant, it also takes several treatment stages:

• The implant post is surgically placed inside your jawbone. This is left to integrate fully with the surrounding bone over 3-6 months.
• Next, an abutment is attached to the implant. This connects the replacement tooth above the gumline.
• Finally, the artificial crown is secured onto the abutment. Your dentist will monitor the implant over time.

While a root canal salvages your natural tooth structure, an implant completely replaces the root and crown portions.

How do success rates compare over time?

Proper care allows a root canal tooth to remain functional for many years. However, studies say that in 15-20% of cases, retreatment or extraction is required around 5-10 years later.

In comparison, dental implants have impressive longevity. The success rate is 95-98% over the first 5 years. Studies following implants for 10-15 years found that 80-90% were still successful and intact.

Over a lifetime, implant success maybe two times higher than root canal treatment. However, results depend on your dental habits, oral health, and grinding or clenching.

What are the healing and recovery times?

After a root canal, your tooth may be sensitive to hot and cold for a few days. There might be minor discomfort as you chew and apply pressure. Complete healing takes about 1-2 weeks.

With a dental implant, there is progressive healing:

• After surgery, swelling and bruising can last up to 1-2 weeks. Discomfort usually subsides within a few days. A soft food diet is recommended.
• Bone healing occurs under the gums over 2-6 months. The implant integrates with your jaw.
• After the abutment and crown, soreness typically lasts only 2-3 days. Most patients can resume normal activity shortly.

Could an implant or root canal be the better choice for you?

When deciding between a root canal or an implant, consider factors like:

• Overall tooth structure – can it support a filling and crown?
• Infection severity – is it treatable or likely to recur?
• Location – front teeth show more. Back teeth handle chewing forces.
• Time – how long the procedure and recovery will take.
• Cost – what’s covered by your insurance, if applicable.
• Long-term outlook – will the tooth/implant last many more years?

Your dentist in North Branch can take x-rays and assess your needs. A meticulously done root canal is worth trying if a natural tooth can be saved. But a deteriorating tooth or one with recurrent issues may be better replaced with a durable, low-maintenance dental implant.

For affordable root canal or implant solutions, contact us at Thumbs Up Dental. Our skilled local practitioners will determine the optimal treatment plan for your long-lasting oral health and smile. Call us now to schedule your consultation!